Modeling Smallmouth Bass Consumption of Round Goby in Lake Erie: Implications for Predator Growth and Contaminant transfer
Project Number: R/ER-055, Progress Report
Start Date: 3/1/2000
Completion Date: 4/13/2007
Revision Date: 10/23/2009
This project made use of Stone Laboratory Research facilities.
Classified Under: Aquatic Nuisance Species
| Principal Investigator(s) | 1. | Roy A. Stein, Evolution, Ecology, and Organismal Biology Ohio State University |
| Co-Principal Investigator(s) | 2. | Susan Fisher, Entomology Ohio State University |
| 3. | Elizabeth A. Marschall, Evolution, Ecology, and Organismal Biology Ohio State University | |
| Associate Investigator(s) | 4. | Gene W. Kim, Evolution, Ecology, and Organismal Biology Ohio State University |
Funding Record
| Source: Ohio Sea Grant College Program | |||
| Source Fund | State Match | Pass Through | |
| First Year | $ 47,918.00 | $ 28,485.00 | $ 0.00 |
| Second Year | $ 47,976.00 | $ 28,791.00 | $ 0.00 |
| Third Year | $ 48,447.00 | $ 25,487.00 | $ 0.00 |
| Total | $ 144,340.00 | $ 84,953.00 | $ 0.00 |
Objectives
To address the complex interactions between round gobies and smallmouth bass, we formulate two general hypotheses:
Hypothesis 1 - Given their increasing numbers in both the environment (i.e., Lake Erie) and in predator stomachs, round gobies will influence smallmouth bass growth dynamics.
Hypothesis 2 - Round gobies will alter contaminant (i.e., polychlorinated biphenyl; PCB) dynamics and eventually increase contaminant concentrations in higher trophic levels (i.e., smallmouth bass).
To address our two hypotheses, we develop specific objectives including the following:
1. To experimentally test the hypothesis that round gobies are preferred prey by smallmouth bass (as compared to emerald shiners Notropis atherinoides, and crayfish Orconectes rusticus).
2. To experimentally test the hypothesis that round gobies are energetically desirable prey for smallmouth bass (by measuring caloric content, lipid content, etc.).
3. To experimentally assess PCB assimilation efficiency and elimination rates for smallmouth bass that ingest PCB-spiked round gobies.
4. To test the hypothesis that consumption of round gobies by smallmouth bass can increase predator growth rates (via bioenergetics modeling).
5. To test the hypothesis that consumption of round gobies will affect PCB bioavailability to smallmouth bass (via our bioenergetics-bioaccumulation model).
6. To forecast and evaluate (based on smallmouth bass diets) a variety of potential dietary exposure pathways for smallmouth bass.
Hypothesis 1 - Given their increasing numbers in both the environment (i.e., Lake Erie) and in predator stomachs, round gobies will influence smallmouth bass growth dynamics.
Hypothesis 2 - Round gobies will alter contaminant (i.e., polychlorinated biphenyl; PCB) dynamics and eventually increase contaminant concentrations in higher trophic levels (i.e., smallmouth bass).
To address our two hypotheses, we develop specific objectives including the following:
1. To experimentally test the hypothesis that round gobies are preferred prey by smallmouth bass (as compared to emerald shiners Notropis atherinoides, and crayfish Orconectes rusticus).
2. To experimentally test the hypothesis that round gobies are energetically desirable prey for smallmouth bass (by measuring caloric content, lipid content, etc.).
3. To experimentally assess PCB assimilation efficiency and elimination rates for smallmouth bass that ingest PCB-spiked round gobies.
4. To test the hypothesis that consumption of round gobies by smallmouth bass can increase predator growth rates (via bioenergetics modeling).
5. To test the hypothesis that consumption of round gobies will affect PCB bioavailability to smallmouth bass (via our bioenergetics-bioaccumulation model).
6. To forecast and evaluate (based on smallmouth bass diets) a variety of potential dietary exposure pathways for smallmouth bass.
Rationale
Exotic species continue to invade and spread. Recently, round gobies have spread rapidly throughout all of the Great Lakes. The invasion by round gobies into areas occupied by zebra mussels Dreissena polymorpha creates problems. Singularly, each of these species can have negative effects on native species via consumption and competition for limited food resources. Taken together, however, these two exotic species can greatly alter energy and contaminant dynamics. They can return contaminants destined for sediment deposition back into the sport-fish food web. Ingestion of zebra mussels by round gobies can complete a food chain from contaminated algae and sediment - zebra mussels - round gobies - smallmouth bass. The recent population explosion and inclusion of round gobies into diets of many sport fishes has raised concern among fishery managers. This concern arises from uncertainty about how the inclusion of round gobies will affect predator growth rates and contaminant concentrations in this growing smallmouth bass fishery.
Methodology
We will conduct an experiment to quantify the feeding rate of smallmouth bass on three prey types (round gobies, crayfish, and emerald shiners), as prey densities increase. We then will conduct predator selection experiments, in which each predator will be allowed to chose among the three prey types. In this experiment, behaviors and predators and prey will be recorded. Measurements of prey responses, predator search time, predator handling of prey, and prey consumption for each prey type will be recorded. We will compare these measurements to energetic gains for round gobies and assess whether round gobies are energetically efficient prey. We then will conduct an assimilation efficiency/elimination rate experiment of smallmouth bass ingesting PCB-spiked round gobies. Finally, we will use these data and species-specific physiological information to parameterize a bioenergetics model for Lake Erie smallmouth bass. From this, we can predict changes in growth rate and PCB bioaccumulation in smallmouth bass, due to their recent dietary inclusion of round gobies.
Benefits & Accomplishments
To date, our progress on specific objectives is as follows:
- Predator preference experiment. Experiment is completed, and preliminary data analyses are done. These results have been presented at scientific meetings (see below).
- Are round gobies are energetically desirable prey for smallmouth bass (by measuring caloric content, lipid content, etc.). We have completed bomb calorimetry for about 150 round gobies from Lake Erie. We will combined these data with our experimental data.
- In 2001, we completed field sampling of our sites for smallmouth bass, round gobies, and zebra mussels. We currently are analyzing these samples for PCB concentrations.
- Dietary PCB uptake in smallmouth bass fed PCB-spiked round gobies. This experiment is ongoing. We currently house 30 smallmouth bass that are being used in this experiment. They have been fed PCB-spiked round gobies. This experiment will end in Feb 2003. Bioenergetic modeling. Winter 2003 .
- Bioenergetics-bioaccumulation model. Winter 2003 To forecast potential dietary exposure pathways for smallmouth bass. Ongoing.
Awards & Patents
| IAGLR/Hydrolab Award for best student paper presentation, at the 45th Annual Meeting of the International Association for Great Lakes Research, IAGLR and HYDROLAB/HACH CORP Award Received: 6/6/2002 | |
| AFS Best Scientific Poster Presentation Award, for the 132nd National Meeting of the American Fisheries Society, Baltimore, MD, 18-22 August. American Fisheries Society Award Received: 8/22/2002 | |
| EEOB Departmental Darwin Award, Best poster presented by an EEOB graduate student during 2002. The Ohio State University. Department of Evolution, Ecology, and Organismal Biology Award Received: 12/31/2002 | |
| University Presidential Fellowship, (based on PhD student research for this project), The Ohio State University, Columbus, Ohio (15 selected from 48 nominations at OSU) Ohio State University Graduate School Award Received: 1/1/2004 | |
| Best Fisheries Poster, The 2004 Annual Ohio Fish and Wildlife Conference Award Received: 2/6/2004 | |
| Sea Grant Knauss Fellowship, Sea Grant Marine Policy Fellow, U.S. House of Representatives, DC. 2005-2006. Sea Grant Award Received: 2/1/2005 |
Publications & Media
| Peer-reviewed Publications | |
| Kwon, T-D, SW Fisher, GW Kim, H.Hwang, and J-E Kim. 2006, Trophic transfer and biotransformation of polychlorinated biphenyls in zebra mussel, round goby, and smallmouth bass in Lake Erie, USA Environmental Toxicology and Chemistry 25:1068-1078 | |
| Kim, GW, MR Gearhiser, SW Fisher, EA Marschall, C Knight, and RA Stein Selective predation by smallmouth bass on exotic round gobies over historical Lake Erie prey: Comparative results from laboratory- and field-based estimates In review at Canadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Science | |
| Kim, GW, AP Wintzer, TK Menker, RA Stein, JM Dettmers, and DR DeVries Benthic-pelagic habitat coupling by omnivorous gizzard shad along a detritus-quality gradient: a multi-scale study. In revision at editor's request at Canadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences. | |
| J. Matthew Lawrence 2004, Bioaccumulation of sediment-associated 2,2',4,4',5,5' hexachlorobiphenyl by Chironomus riparius, Lumbriculus variegatus, and Hyalella azteca. Master's Thesis, Department of Entomology, Ohio State University | |
| Martin, Lynne M. 2005, Determination of polychlorinated biphenyl levels in cyprinidae and a trophic level assessment of potential biomagnification of polychlorinated biphenyls in Chelydra serpentina from the Lake Erie region Master's Thesis, Department of Entomology, Ohio State University | |
| Kim, G.W., T-D Kwon, J.R. Flanary, R.A. Stein, E.A. Marschall, and S.W. Fisher. Exotic species influence biomagnification of polychlorinated biphenyls in a Great Lakes benthic food web. In preparation. (29 page of text, 2 tables, and 7 figures) | |
| Kim, G.W., S.W. Fisher, R.A. Stein, and E.A. Marschall. The role of dreissenid mussels, sediment characteristics, and organic pollutants in structuring nearshore benthic macroinvertebrate communities in Lake Erie. In preparation. (20 pages of text, 8 tables, 4 figures) | |
| Presentations | |
| Kim, G.W., M R. Gearhiser, C.T. Knight, E.A. Marschall, S.W. Fisher, and R.A. Stein. 2002, Selective predation by Smallmouth Bass on Round Goby, Emerald Shiner, and Crayfish Platform presentation at the 45th Annual Meeting of the International Association for Great Lakes Research, Winnipeg, Manitoba, 2-6 June. | |
| Kim, G.W., E.A. Marschall, S.W. Fisher, and R.A. Stein. 2002, Lake Erie benthic food webs: effect of exotic species on energy and PCB flow. Invited platform presentation at the 2002 Ohio Division of Wildlife Annual Research Review Meeting, Columbus, Ohio, 14-15 February. | |
| Kim, G.W., A.N. Patel, T.K. Menker, J.M. Dettmers, R.A. Wright, D.R. DeVries, and R.A. Stein. 2004, Density and sediment detritus influence gizzard shad growth and survival Poster presentation at the 44th Ohio Fish and Wildlife Conference, Columbus, Ohio, 6 February 2004. | |
| Kim, G. W., T-D. Kwon, M.R. Gearhiser, E.A. Marschall, S.W. Fisher, and R.A. Stein 2003, PCB Biomagnification in the zebra mussel - round goby - smallmouth bass food chain in Lake Erie Platform presentation at the 133rd Annual Meeting of the American Fisheries Society, Québec City, Québec, Canada, 10-14 August. | |
| Kim, G.W., A.N. Patel, T.K. Menker, J.M. Dettmers, R.A. Wright, D.R. DeVries, and R.A. Stein 2002, Detritus quality and fish density influence gizzard shad growth and survival Poster presentation at the 132nd Annual Meeting of the American Fisheries Society, Baltimore, MD, 18-22 August. | |
| Kim, G.W., M.R. Gearhiser, E.A. Marschall, C.T. Knight, S.W. Fisher, and R.A. Stein 2002, Comparing laboratory and field estimates of predation by smallmouth bass on round goby, emerald shiner, and crayfish Platform presentation at the 132nd Annual Meeting of the American Fisheries Soc., Baltimore, MD, 18-22 August. | |
| Kim, G. W., T-D. Kwon, M.R. Gearhiser, E.A. Marschall, S.W. Fisher, and R.A. Stein. 2004, PCB Biomagnification in the zebra mussel - round goby - smallmouth bass food chain in Lake Erie Platform presentation at the 44th Ohio Fish and Wildlife Conference, Columbus, Ohio, 6 February. | |
| Website & Electronic publications | |
| Carolyn Gramling, Great Lakes Radio Consortium 2003, Invasives altering Great Lakes food web Radio interview about Gene Kim's dissertation research. Running Time: 5:42. http://www.glrc.org/story.php3?story_id=2123 | |
| Carolyn Gramling, WOSU Science Reporter 2003, Lake Erie invaders pass harmful agents up food chain Public radio interview about Gene Kim's dissertation research. http://www.publicbroadcasting.net/wosu/news.newsmain?action=article&ARTICLE_ID=560065 | |
| Theses/dissertations | |
| Gene W. Kim 2007, Trophic transfer of energy and polychlorinated biphenyls by native and exotic fish in Lake Erie. PhD Dissertation, Department of Evolution, Ecology, and Organismal Biology, Ohio State University | |
Supported Students
| Gene Wook Kim (Graduate, Ph.D. - anticipated 2005) The Ohio State University | |
| Lawrence, Matt (Graduate, M.S. - 2004) The Ohio State University Title: Bioaccumulation of sediment-associated 2,2',4,4',5,5' hexachlorobiphenyl by Chironomus riparius, Lumbriculus variegatus, and Hyalella azteca |
