Click here to Jump to Main Content

Ohio Sea Grant College Program
and Stone Laboratory

Ohio Sea Grant and Stone Laboratory

Sonochemical Desorption of Contaminant Mixtures from Sediment

Project Number: R/PS-030, Progress Report

Start Date: 3/1/2003

Completion Date: 2/28/2005

Revision Date: 8/25/2009

Classified Under: Habitat Restoration

Principal Investigator(s)1.Linda K. Weavers, The Ohio State University*
Co-Principal Investigator(s)2.Samuel J. Traina, University of California, Merced
Associate Investigator(s)3.Richard T. Sayre, Biochemistry and Plant Biology The Ohio State University*
This shows the current affiliation and may not match affiliation at time of participation. *

Funding Record

Source: Ohio Sea Grant College Program
Source FundState MatchPass Through
Total$ 92,897.00$ 78,785.00$ 0.00

Objectives

The purpose of this project is to investigate the application of ultrasound to sediment polluted with a mixture of inorganic and/or organic contaminants. The specific, the goals of this research are:
to determine the ability of sonochemical techniques to treat a series of metals and organic contaminants with different binding strengths to model sediment particles;
to demonstrate the combined degradation of an organic and desorption and recovery of a metal using freeze-dried Chlamydomonas reinhardtii cells; and
to identify key design variables in the sonochemical remediation of sediments contaminated by a mixture of contaminants.

Rationale

Contaminated sediments have been identified as a major source of ecological impacts throughout the entire Great Lakes Basin. Contaminated sediments result in fish consumption advisories that adversely affect sport and commercial fishing industries. In addition, contaminated sediments threaten the viability of commercial ports due to the increased cost of dredging sediment that requires disposal at a confined disposal facility. The development of sonication as a treatment technology will provide an alternate solution to existing sediment remediation technologies. Existing treatment technologies such as capping or removal to a confined disposal facility have the limitation that the pollutants are not destroyed and pose a future risk. Conversely, sonication of sediments can be performed on a ship, and since sonication desorbs and transforms the contaminants, the sediments can be replaced after treatment while the aqueous phase receives further treatment by freeze-dried algal biomass prior to replacement. Knowledge of the mechanism of sonochemical desorption will give insight into its applicability to a variety of remediation scenarios.

Methodology

The investigation of removal, transformation, and characterization of the removal mechanisms will occur in distinct phases. Initially, we will study the removal of metals from well-characterized model sediment systems. In this set of experiments we will learn the role of particle composition and organic matter on removal of a series of metals from sediments. In addition, we will investigate the ability of genetically altered biomass to remove the released metals from the aqueous stream. Next, we will investigate the removal and transformation of a series of PAHs with differing binding strengths to the well-characterized model sediments. In the final series of experiments, we will investigate sonochemical desorption and destruction with a mixture of metals, organics, or metals and organics with the model sediments and subsequent treatment of the aqueous stream with freeze-dried Chlamydomonas reinhardtii cells. Knowledge obtained in the mixed system will be used to understand the removal and degradation of metals and organics from real sediment.

Benefits & Accomplishments

Desorption of four different metals, Pb2+, Hg2+, Ni2+, and Cr3+, from a model inorganic sediment, Al2O3, has been conducted under similar conditions using sonication and hydrodynamic mixing. For Pb2+ and Hg2+ with very fast water exchange rates (kPb2+-H2O = 7 x 109 s-1 and kHg2+-H2O = 2 x 109 s-1, respectively), during the first few minutes of sonication, desorption by sonication was enhanced compared to hydrodynamic mixing. However, with longer sonication times, the release by sonication decreased with time, while the desorption by hydrodynamic mixing appeared to reach equilibrium. At 60 min, less desorption occurred by sonication than that by hydrodynamic mixing, especially for Hg2+. Comparatively, for metals with slower water exchange kinetics namely Ni2+ (kNi2+-H2O = 3 x 104 s-1) and Cr3+ (kCr3+-H2O = 5 x 10-7 s-1), sonication also enhanced their desorption compared to hydrodynamic mixing. Unlike Pb2+ and Hg2+, the reduced desorption with longer sonication times was not observed for Ni2+ and Cr3+ even at 3 hr.

The enhanced release by sonication at short times may be attributed to the extreme conditions generated during the violent collapse of cavitation bubbles. The reduced desorptions observed with Pb2+ and Hg2+ at longer sonication times were likely due to the fast resorption. Due to the relatively slow water exchange kinetic constants of Ni2+and Cr3+ compared to Pb2+ and Hg2+, Ni2+ and Cr3+ do not show the fast resorption, which leads to the decrease in Pb2+ and Hg2+ release with longer sonication. Considering their different water exchange kinetics, which usually determine the adsorption rates, it is obvious that ultrasound is capable of releasing metals from Al2O3. The net desorption is kinetically determined by: 1) the desorption effects of sonication and 2) the resorption combined with the particle changes induced by ultrasound.

Sonication also enhanced the release of the four metals (Pb2+, Hg2+, Ni2+, and Cr) from standard sediment PACS-2 (purchased from NRC) at pH 8.0 compared to hydrodynamic mixing.  However, the difference between different metals is not as obvious as that from Al2O3 particles.  In acidic condition (pH 3.0), sonication enhanced Pd2+ and Ni2+ releases compared to those at pH 8.0, whereas decreased Hg2+ and Cr release compared to those at pH 8.0.  The interesting thing was that at pH 3.0, ultrasonic release of Pb2+ was lower that by hydrodynamic mixing.  Longer sonication times (3 hr) led to decreases in the release of metals except for Ni2+ release at pH 3.0.  Sonication significantly increased organic matter release at pH 8.0.  But at pH 3.0, ultrasonic release of organic matter was not obviously higher than that by hydrodynamic mixing, even lower than that by hydrodynamic mixing at pH 8.0.

The different releases of various metals at different pH values were likely due to the differences in their contents, different sediment compositions, sorption modes, metal species, and the effects of organic matters in sediment.  For example, Hg2+ release was likely controlled by organic matter; Cr release was influenced by its species; whereas Pb2 +and Ni2+ seemed to be affected by inorganic mineral phases.

The characterization of sediments and experiments on real sediments from Ashtabula River is being carried out to investigate the effects of organic matter and different compositions of sediment on the release of various metals. Molecular level examination of metal complexation and adsorption modes will also help to understand the mechanism of sonolytic release.

The application of ultrasound combined with biomass (transgenic Chlamydomonas reinhardtii, a green alga) for the removal of Hg from model and real sediments (Al2O3, a-HgS, and PACS-2 marine sediment) was investigated. A transgenic Chlamydomonas reinhardtii (2AMT-2) expressing a plasmamembrane-anchored metallothionein polymer effectively recovered Hg(II) released into the aqueous phase by sonication over a broad pH range from 2.0 to 9.0.  The results showed that this combined technique of ultrasound and alga biomass (2AMT-2) was effective to remove Hg from solids and sediments, especially from Al2O3 and a-HgS with no natural organic matter.  An implication of the results of this study is that the application of ultrasound and biomass (transgenic C. reinhardtii) has the potential for in-situ Hg removal from contaminated inorganic sediments.

To effectively recover Hg from organic sediments, the competition for Hg binding between algae and NOM must be considered. Effective means for containing algal cells but allowing direct interaction of alga and Hg-NOM complexes would likely greatly improve algal uptake of Hg.  Further work is needed to determine parameters for optimum operations such as biomass replacement and sonication conditions. 

Desorption of three polyaromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs), naphthalene, phenanthrene and pyrene, from natural sediment will be studied. The sonochemical degradation of these PAHs in aqueous phase was investigated to determine the importance of factors such as temperature, concentration, Henry's constant and reactivity with hydroxyl radicals. The result obtained suggested that Henry's constant cannot fully account for the trend observed in semi-volatile contaminant. PAHs are able to reactant through the hydroxyl radical pathway in the bulk as well as through pyrolysis in the bubble.

In order to study the desorption mechanism, humic acid aged a-Al2O3 were used as a model sediment. PAHs were added to the humic acid laden a-Al2O3 and allowed to sorb for one week. Automated Soxhlet Extraction was used to extract the PAHs from the sediment. Recovery ranges from 87-93%. This model sediment will be sonicated to determine the rate of desorption and degradation of PAHs.

Publications & Media

Peer-reviewed Publications
Peer-reviewed PublicationsZ. He, S. Siripornadulsil, R. Sayre, S. J. Traina, and L. K. Weavers 2006, Remediation of mercury from sediment by ultrasound combined with biomass (transgenic Chlamydomonas reinhardtii)
Submitted to Environmental Science & Technology
Presentations
PresentationsZ. He, L. K. Weavers, R. Sayre, and S. Traina 2006, Remediation of mercury contaminated sediment by ultrasound combined with transgenic Chlamydomonas reinhardtii
Gordon Research Conferences on Environmental Sciences: Water. Poster presentation. Plymouth NH, June 25-30, 2006
PresentationsZ. He, L. K. Weavers, S. Siripornadulsil, and R. Sayre 2006, Removal of mercury from sediment by ultrasound combined with biomass (transgenic Chlamydomonas reinhardtii)
231st ACS National Meeting, Poster presentation. Atlanta GA, March 26-30, 2006
PresentationsM. Pee, Z. He, L. K. Weavers 2005, Sonochemical desorption and destruction of contaminant mixtures (Metals & PAHs) from freshwater sediments
Battelle Forum II. Poster presentation. Columbus, OH, November 28, 2005
PresentationsL. K. Weavers 2003, Sonochemical Desorption and Degradation of Pollutants from River Sediments
Environmental Science Graduate Program, The Ohio State University, Columbus, OH, October 10, 2003
PresentationsZ. He, M. Pee, L. K. Weavers 2007, Sonochemical desorption and destruction of contaminant mixtures from freshwater sediment
37th Mid-Atlantic Industrial and Hazardous Waste Conference (MAIHWC), Cincinnati OH, March 21-23, 2007.

Supported Students

StudentZiqi He (Graduate, Ph.D.)
The Ohio State University
Thesis Title: Sonochemical remediation of mercury from contaminated sediments
StudentMaggie Pee (Graduate, PhD)
The Ohio State University
Thesis Title: Desorption of PAHs from natural sediment