Click here to Jump to Main Content

Ohio Sea Grant College Program
and Stone Laboratory

Ohio Sea Grant and Stone Laboratory

Expanding delivery modes for education about Great Lakes Systems

Project Number: E/TER-002, Completion Report

Start Date: 3/1/2002

Completion Date: 2/28/2005

Revision Date: 4/27/2009

This project made use of Stone Laboratory Research facilities.

Principal Investigator(s)1.Rosanne W Fortner, COSEE Great Lakes*
Co-Principal Investigator(s)2.Joseph L. Arvai, The Ohio State University*
This shows the current affiliation and may not match affiliation at time of participation. *

Funding Record

Source: Ohio Sea Grant College Program
Source FundState MatchPass Through
First Year$ 45,164.00$ 34,680.00$ 0.00
Second Year$ 56,360.00$ 36,887.00$ 0.00
Third Year$ 49,646.00$ 39,155.00$ 0.00
Total$ 151,171.00$ 110,723.00$ 0.00

Objectives

The project goal is to increase the geographic and scientific literacy of Ohio's secondary teachers and students through expanded access to and appropriate use of data about the interdisciplinary sciences of the Great Lakes and how the lake systems change over time. To accomplish this goal the three-year project will
· make available to secondary science classes a set of new classroom activities using current Great Lakes data that address the subject matter objectives and process skills for the Ohio proficiency assessments;
· provide Sea Grant outreach to informal science education institutions on the south shore of Lake Erie, and col-laborate through them to reach additional education audiences;
· utilize on-line access and distance learning to facilitate access to Sea Grant/Great Lakes materials and data among teachers and students who cannot directly reach Stone Laboratory or other Ohio Sea Grant facilities and personnel;
· include in new curriculum delivery modes the teaching of skills reflecting the state of the art in the decision sciences, so that people may utilize their enhanced scientific literacy for individual and group decisions about environmental issues related to Lake Erie and the Great Lakes system.

Rationale

For nearly 25 years the Ohio Sea Grant Education Program has been serving teachers in the Great Lakes region through classroom curriculum development, teacher enhancement workshops and credit courses, and contributions to the research literature that informs best practice. Changes in the audience of teachers, and new pressures on their ways of assisting learning, require that education delivery methods expand and move in new directions. While the systems we have been using are not "broken," they may be in need of an upgraded model for new times and new needs. We wish to involve more teachers in Great Lakes learning and teaching, but reliance on hard-copy materials and on-site professional development tells the audience we may not be in tune with modern opportunities and challenges. The new delivery modes will be e-curricula for students, distance education for teachers, and informal learning for both groups as well as the public that visits science/nature facilities.

Through development and implementation of these delivery modes, Ohio Sea Grant, with its Great Lakes science data and education expertise, will

  • Expand the range of available Sea Grant materials into high school levels
  • Introduce decision sciences into consideration of Great Lakes issues
  • Demonstrate outreach through informal education networking
  • Make effective use of distance learning for teachers' professional development
  • Compile new forms of innovative curricula, in adaptable formats for available school technology
  • Assist schools in meeting Ohio science standards for graduation
  • Disseminate research data to new user groups.

Methodology

The project will have three components whose tasks will be the focus of individual project years but which will culminate in the accomplishment of the overall goal at project end. They build upon each other and continue to pro-gress with input from participants (teachers and educators in informal institutions). In all the tasks we will build in the use of decision making tools: defining decision perspectives, making choices under uncertainty, and thinking about consequences. Deliberate attention to such aspects of Great Lakes science will make these education delivery modes unique in their contribution to Great Lakes education in Sea Grant.

Task 1. E-Curriculum development using Data from Research on Lake Erie
Using newly available databases on biological diversity and physical parameters of the Great Lakes, experienced teachers will work with project staff to develop high school curriculum activities that address specific parts of the Ohio Proficiency exam for graduation, and are primarily based in classroom technology to use interdisciplinary science. Access to Internet databases, while optimal for use of the curricula, will be facilitated with hard-copy sam-ples that feature downloadable database segments for use off-line. E-curriculum use will be encouraged through professional presentations by the project staff and developing teachers.

Task 2. Guide to Informal Education Opportunities for Great Lakes Systems
Educators from informal education facilities (museums, nature centers, etc.) on the south shore of Lake Erie will be joined in a consortium designed to let secondary schools know what they collectively and individually provide for meeting state standards and using Lake Erie subject matter. Packets of information will be assembled for schools and projects will be designed to attract secondary school groups to the facilities for science learning. Teachers will be employed to work with the facilities to develop ideas for higher cognitive curricula that will appeal to high schools. Decision making challenges will involve the public in dialogues with science as well.

Task 3. Offer Continuing Education Modules for teacher enhancement by distance learning
Teachers in Ohio and most other states are required to continue their educational growth, and they may do so by a variety of means that do not always involve University credits. Using the data and activities from Tasks 1-2, combined with existing Ohio Sea Grant Education materials, this project will construct brief modules for Great Lakes science and geography education via asynchronous distance learning. Each module will be designed to involve about 6-8 hours of content exploration and application in the classroom.

Evaluation of all three proposed tasks will be ongoing, so that mid-course corrections can be made to respond to what we are learning from the audience and from the cooperating teachers who are the critical summer staff. Several types of output and outcome measures will be collected. More difficult impact measures will sought as well both in the project period and beyond. These will be focused on the decision making aspects of scientific literacy, as personal choices relate to environmental issues of the Great Lakes.

Benefits & Accomplishments

Co-PIs team taught a 3-credit course in Curriculum Development for Environmental Decision Making, at Stone Lab in Summer 2002. Student assignments became the basis for curriculum development by the GRA and staff.

Three teachers were hired from the course to construct curriculum materials and test them through the academic year. Development is in progress. An internet site with 12 Great Lakes Decision Activities is now public at http://earthsys.sg.ohio-state.edu/decision/. The materials have been pilot tested in central Ohio Schools and revisions are complete. We see the need for additional topics, so we will incorporate development into courses taught in the coming year.

Four teachers were hired for summer assistance in Year 2 to collect information about informal education institutions that do Great Lakes programs in the Lake Erie watershed. Their reports are being used to construct an on-line searchable database for teachers.

The database was completed in summer 2004 and can be found on-line at http://earthsys.ag.ohio-state.edu/erieed. It contains over 100 informal education facilities in four states and is searchable by either geographic region, type of activity, or Lake Erie topic.

Publications & Media

Peer-reviewed Publications
PDF: Fortner, R.W., Arvai, J., Dudley, J.E. and Froschauer, A 2003, Instructional materials for environmental decision making
Proceedings of the 32nd Annual Conference of the North American Association for Environmental Education. In press. Made available by Ohio Sea Grant as OHSU-RS-352.
Peer-reviewed PublicationsDudley, Jennifer and Fortner, R.W 2003, The effect of participation in place-based environmental education programs on student affect toward science: A case study of F.T. Stone Laboratory's middle school program
Proceedings of the 32nd Annual Conference of the North American Association for Environmental Education. In press.
Peer-reviewed PublicationsRosanne W. Fortner, Lisa M. Bircher, Sara White, Hongxia Duan, Paul Genzman, Becky Lippman, and Melissa Simons. 2004, Teacher Education at Stone Laboratory: Program description, literature setting, and impact on educators
Technical Report TB-076. Columbus: Ohio Sea Grant College Program. 42 pp.
Peer-reviewed PublicationsFortner, R.W. 2004, Beam Me Up! Videoconferences Extend Stone Lab Learning
Twine Line 26(1): 4.
Peer-reviewed PublicationsR.W. Fortner [Ed]. 2004, Special issue on marine education
Science Activities 40(1).
Peer-reviewed PublicationsSara White. 2004, Ballast blockade: Stopping aquatic immigrants
Science Activities 40(1).
Peer-reviewed PublicationsArvai, J. L., Campbell, V. E. A., Baird, A., & Rivers, L. 2004, Teaching students to make better decisions about the environment: Lessons from the decision sciences
Journal of Environmental Education, 36, 33-44.
Presentations
PresentationsRosanne Fortner, Joe Arvai and Jennifer Malinowski. 2004, Sea Grant Educators Using the Internet: Interactive web-based activities for learning and decision making
Great Lakes Sea Grant Network meeting, September.
PresentationsFortner, R.W. 2003, Sediments, seasons and ships: Teaching about the Earth system with Lake Erie examples
Environmental Education Council of Ohio
PresentationsRosanne W. Fortner, Joe L. Arvai, J.E. 2003, Instructional materials for environmental decision making
NAAEE Annual Conference, October 10.
PresentationsLyndsey Manzo. 2004, Evaluating the use of a structured decision-making framework as a method of teaching about environmental issues
Presented at the first annual SNR Graduate Seminar. May.
PresentationsRosanne Fortner, Robin Goettel and Jennifer Malinowski. 2004, Educators respond to invasive species: Interactive web-based activities for learning and decision making
Presented at the 13th International Conference on Aquatic Invasive Species, Ennis, Ireland.
PresentationsFortner, Malinowski and Goettel, Robin. 2004, Classroom technology for learning and decision making about invasive species
[poster] Presented at the 13th International Conference on Aquatic Invasive Species, Ennis, Ireland.
PresentationsFortner, Goettel, Malinowski and Hyonyong Lee. 2004, Interactive web-based education about watershed invaders
[poster] Presented at the Annual conference of the North American Association for Environmental Education, Biloxi, MS. October.

Supported Students

StudentAnn Froschauer (Graduate, M.S.)
The Ohio State University
StudentSara White (Graduate, M.S.)
The Ohio State University
Title: Environmental attitudes of high school students attending college courses at F.T. Stone Laboratory
StudentJeremy King (Graduate, M.S.)
The Ohio State University
StudentDudley, Jennifer (Graduate, M.S.)
The Ohio State University
Title: The effect of participation in place-based environmental education programs on student affect toward science: A case study of F.T. Stone Laboratory's middle school program
StudentPaul Genzman (Graduate, M.S.)
The Ohio State University
Title: Developing proficiency in systems thinking among secondary science students at Put-in-Bay School through sequential use of concept mapping
StudentKaren Cook Hoggarth (Graduate, M.S.)
The Ohio State University
StudentManzo, Lyndsey (Graduate, M.S.)
The Ohio State University
Title: Evaluating the use of a structured decision-making framework as a method of teaching about environmental issues
StudentDuan, Hongxia (Graduate, Ph.D.)
The Ohio State University
Thesis Title: SOCIAL PROCESS OF ENVIRONMENTAL RISK PERCEPTION, PREFERENCES OF RISK MANAGEMENT AND PUBLIC PARTICIPATION IN DECISION MAKING: A CROSS-CULTURAL STUDY BETWEEN THE UNITED STATES AND CHINA. Made available by Ohio Sea Grant as OHSU-TD-107 result of E-TER-002.
StudentKim, Chan Kook (Graduate, Ph.D.)
The Ohio State University